Celebrating July 4th in the Trump Years: Make it Inter-Dependence Day to Challenge the Ideology of Right Wing Ultra-Nationalism
by Rabbi Michael Lerner editor Tikkun magazine
A July 4th “ Seder”
In past years, faced with July 4th celebrations that are focused on militarism, ultra-nationalism, and “bombs bursting in air,” many American families who do not share those values turned July 4th into another summer holiday focused on picnics, sports and fireworks while doing their best to avoid the dominant rhetoric and bombast. During the Trump years we all have a moral obligation to
use this holiday to challenge the “America First” ultra-nationalist worldview that Trump and Right-wing activists are trying to popularize as they shift the mainstream dialogue from its previous center-right blandly pro-capitalist worldview to an extremist right-wing nationalism, already mobilized against environmental protections, that could provide the foundation both for new wars (against Iran, North Korea, or even Russia or China) and for an assault on whatever remains standing of the New Deal of the 1930s (workers’ rights to organize unions, safety and health regulations, Medicare, retirement benefits, public education, social security, etc.)
Yet the key to challenging this direction is to not fall into two traps that have limited the support for liberal and progressive forces: a. thinking that the alternative to ultra-nationalism is to focus only on what is wrong with America, thereby handing to the extremists the banner of being the only pro-American voice; or b. demeaning all those who have supported Trump as racists, sexists, homophobes, xenophobes, antiSemites or just plain stupid. The shaming and blaming only strengthens the support of many for Trumpist politics, and must cease. Instead, we need to reclaim all that is good in America, and reframe that in terms of celebrating July 4th as Inter-dependence day. We in the Network of Spiritual Progressives believe that that there is much worth celebrating in American history that deserves attention on July 4th, though it is rarely the focus of the public events.