“This Conversation Never Happened”

by Jeremy Bendik-Keymer 
 

I was sitting in Rising Star Roasters in Ohio City, Cleveland, Ohio when two loud-mouthed millennials sat next to me.  They filled the whole room with their discussion of a building they are making to house yoga, a workout room and other things.  It was as if they couldn’t find their worth unless the whole room saw it reflected in their access to property and investment. I was reading and so mostly shut out the discussion that followed of skylights, boiler systems, and ducting -the latter two of which I often find really interesting, given that I love to think about how we can build homes intricately, solidly and sustainably.  What if I had read out loud, very loud, my chapter, “Compassion:  tragic predicaments” so that the whole room filled with the words of Martha Nussbaum?  (I should do that sometime, the next time a person shouts into a cell phone -go up next to them and start reading REALLY LOUDLY.)

But there came a point where my mind told me I should be listening.  The builder said to the client, back-pedaling from some difficulty the client faced and which would possibly cause moral problems for the builder: “This conversation never happened.”  He implied that they can just act as if he had never heard the difficulty. The problem is, the conversation did happen.  That’s the truth.  The builder went on blithely through the remaining minutes.  I couldn’t figure out what had been avoided, but he seemed happy.  The client went to the bathroom, and the builder bounced around the place with a CAVS hat on until they both left.  No problem.  The conversation happened, and they will suppress it if accountability ever arises. Need I say that this is our society now?  “This conversation never happened” is a cliché you can speak loudly in public space while you are trying to vacuum some money away from people’s pockets. We live in an arbitrary society.  Our president is an arbitrarian –he is accountable to no rule.  Major “news” sources are increasingly arbitrarian -they drive people who have served our country to leave in protest due to their disregard of truth.  Even good educational institutions will say that they value X in education -say, “ethics”- but unintentionally omit structured ethical learning and moral education across the university educational experience.  Mission statements seem to be mere fluff, and the faculty that should have helped create them irrelevant -the space of the university, then:  arbitrary.